[Bnomic-private] Judgement on CFI 977

[Glotmorf]

On 9/6/02 at 2:25 AM Joshua Caudle wrote:

>I judge False on CFI 977.
>
>Analysis:  In part A Orc attempts to resaon that because f the inclusivity
>of the language provided by rule 503,  rule 636 has no application,
>however,
>rule 33 states "each rule has an attribute called Chutzpah, which is a
>positive integer, in the event of a conflict between two or more rules,=
 the
>tiule with the highest Chutzpah takes precedence." therefore since  rule
>636
>has a chutzpah of 2 and rule 503 only has a chutzpah of 1. it is illegal=
 to
>remove from players items in eir possession. this therefore makes all=
 other
>parts of said arguement moot.
>
>However:
>I myself am placing a call for inquiry on this same action.
>
>Statement: Any player according to the rulset as of nweek 22 nday 5 may
>drinka glass of Champagne by simply announcing that the action in taking
>place in a public forum. if no particular glass is stated in said
>proclamation, the admistrator must choose an otherwise unclaimed glasss of
>Champagne for the player to drink. If no such glasses exist the
>administrator must create said glass.
>
>Argument:
>Rule 503 in nweek 22 does not state that a glass must be in a player's
>possesion inorder for the player to drink said glass. However since Rule
>636
>has greater Chutzpah athan Rule 503 the glass cannot be in the possession
>of
>another player. Therefore it si the duty of the adminisytrator to selecta
>legal glass for consumption as stated in Rule 25. If no appropiate glasses
>are currently available, Rule 25 would also plae the onus of creating said
>glass on the administrator.

This was handled by an earlier CFI.

Since a glass of champagne is an alcoholic beverage, and since there is a=
 rule providing for the creation of generic alcoholic beverages, the=
 creation of glasses of champagne is regulated.  Since it is regulated,=
 there can be no not-explicitly-rule-stated procedure for the creation of a=
 glass of champagne.

Rule 25 doesn't apply in this case.  The creation of a glass of champagne=
 isn't a duty not assigned  to other players.  It's a gamestate change, and=
 that's managed by the administrator already.

How many times are we gonna spank this puppy?

						Glotmorf